Skip to main content

Correlation between hospital charges, patient satisfaction, and physician communication

The positive correlation between hospital costs and quality was debunked long ago, nonetheless it's still interesting to look at the data in new ways. Here I've combined two different data sets: first I took the hospital charge data that was published earlier this year by CMS and compared it against patient satisfaction or "perception" data from HCAHPS:


Let me explain the graph. Each circle represents an individual hospital. The x-axis represents patient satisfaction as measured by the HCAHPS question representing the percentage of patients giving their inpatient visit a score of a "9" or a "10." The y-axis represents the average charge (the amount the hospital billed Medicare, not necessarily the amount the hospital actually got paid) by the hospital for management of sepsis, which I am using as a surrogate measure for hospital charges overall. I chose sepsis because it is a common medical syndrome for which we have lots of data and recommendations, and it is a high-risk syndrome whose proper treatment requires all the different moving parts of a hospital to be well functioning. Therefore, I think it is a good indication of hospital functioning and efficiency. Or, in other words, hospitals that follow sepsis protocols really well will probably have shorter hospital stays and therefore smaller charges (this is my hypothesis). The color of the circle represents to what degree the patients perceived that doctors communicated with them (HCAHPS data, see my other recent posts); green means the patients perceived more and better communication with the doctor and red the opposite.

The boundary cases are really interesting: Oklahoma Heart Hospital and Hamlin Memorial Hospital may represent the best "values" when measured by my mechanism above. They each have very high satisfaction scores, along with some of the smallest charges, and very high rates of communication by doctors. On the other hand, Crozer Chester Medical Center in Pennsylvania appears to have much lower satisfaction scores and significantly higher charges, as well as poor physician communication.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

MasteringMedicare Medicare Cheat Sheet updated

 I'm excited to share the newest version, for 2021, of our MasteringMedicare Medicare Cheat Sheet. Feel free to share and provide feedback with suggestions and corrections.  Link to download the Medicare Cheet Sheet:  https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Nu45djmYDln7mSNG0v2Q57pkiACFvRv4/view?usp=sharing

Mastering Medicare Cheat Sheet

Amy Schiffman and I have created an awesome 1-page Medicare Cheat Sheet. You can get it for free by joining the Mastering Medicare subscriber list . Here's a sneak peak

Information about Medicare Advantage plans, coverage and benefits

Information about Medicare Advantage plans, coverage and benefits is available on this website, Medicare Advantage Information . Some topics covered include: additional benefits for medicare additional medicare benefits medicare advantage blue medicare advantage blue cross medicare advantage blue cross blue shield advantage c medicare advantage care plan medicare advantage cost medicare advantage d medicare advantage dental plan medicare advantage health care plans medicare advantage health plan medicare advantage insurance medicare advantage insurance plans medicare advantage of medicare advantage plan advantage of plan advantage plan insurance advantage plans with dental advantage policy advantages of medicare advantage advantages of medicare for all advantages of original medicare benefit medicare